Three New York Giants quarterbacks have been recognized as some of the best to ever play in the NFL, as they have earned a spot on a top 25 quarterback list for the entire 21st century. However, there is one notable omission from this list – two-time Super Bowl champion, Eli Manning.
The list, compiled by a panel of experts and analysts, includes some of the greatest quarterbacks to ever grace the gridiron. Names like Tom Brady, Peyton Manning, and Drew Brees are among those who made the cut. But for Giants fans, it may come as a surprise that their beloved quarterback, Eli Manning, did not make the list.
Manning, who spent his entire 16-year career with the Giants, is no stranger to being overlooked and underestimated. Despite leading the team to two Super Bowl victories and earning Super Bowl MVP twice, he has often been overshadowed by his more decorated brother, Peyton Manning, and other star quarterbacks in the league.
But this latest snub has caused an uproar among fans and experts alike. Many argue that Manning’s achievements and contributions to the Giants’ success over the years should have earned him a spot on the list. After all, he holds the franchise record for most passing yards (57,023) and passing touchdowns (366). He also ranks seventh all-time in both categories.
In addition to his impressive stats, Manning’s clutch performances in the playoffs and ability to come through in crucial moments have solidified his legacy as a top quarterback in the NFL. His game-winning drives in both Super Bowl victories against the New England Patriots are etched in football history and are a testament to his resilience and leadership on the field.
So, why was Manning left off the list? Some argue that his regular season performances were not strong enough to warrant a spot among the elite quarterbacks of the 21st century. But others believe that his lack of individual awards, such as Pro Bowl selections and All-Pro honors, may have played a role in the snub.
Regardless of the reasons, it is clear that many feel Manning has been robbed of the recognition he deserves. The Giants organization has even joined in on the conversation, posting a tweet that reads, “No Eli Manning, no credibility” in response to the list.
But Manning himself has remained humble and gracious, choosing to focus on the positive aspects of his career rather than dwell on the snub. In an interview with ESPN, he stated, “I don’t think it’s something I spend a lot of time thinking about. I know I’ve played in some big games and I’ve been in some important moments, and I’ve won a lot of games in the fourth quarter. I’m proud of that.”
Despite the disappointment of not making the list, Manning’s legacy as one of the greatest quarterbacks in Giants history remains intact. His contributions to the team and his impact on the city of New York cannot be overlooked or diminished by a list.
And while it may be easy to get caught up in the controversy and debate surrounding the snub, it is important to remember that lists and rankings are subjective. They do not define a player’s worth or their impact on the game.
In the end, Manning’s legacy will be remembered by his achievements on the field and the impact he had on the Giants organization and its fans. And for that, he will always be a top quarterback in the hearts of Giants fans, regardless of what any list may say.
